Will My Second-Year Tax Bill Double? A Freelancer's Guide to Advance Payments

The 'double bill' is usually last year's tax plus a first advance on this year's. Once you know whether it applies, it stops being a shock.

Two friends talk over coffee on a sunny balcony while a young man listens with a slightly worried look about his tax bill

Video version: Why your second freelance tax bill can look double

Coming soon. Everything in the video is in the written guide below.

A freelancer's second-year tax bill can look double because, in some systems, the first bill after your first return includes last year's tax plus an advance payment towards this year. It is not extra tax, just earlier tax. Find out now whether advance payments apply to you, and keep saving at your full rate so the pot covers both parts.

Sound familiar?

"A friend said her second-year tax bill was basically double. Is that going to happen to me?"

You probably heard about this for the first time over coffee or a drink, as a horror story, and nobody explained what was actually going on.

Your desired outcome

You know before the bill arrives whether an advance payment applies to you, roughly how big it might be, and your Tax Pot is already growing to cover it.

What the "double bill" really is

Employees pay tax as they earn. Freelancers often pay later, after filing a return. Tax authorities do not love waiting a year or more for that money, so many of them ask self-employed people to pay part of the current year's tax in advance.

In the UK this is called payments on account. Other countries have instalments, estimated payments or prepayments. The names differ, but the pattern is similar. In many of these systems, nothing is asked in advance in your first year, because there is no history to base it on; others expect instalments from the start, so check yours. Then the first return creates that history.

So the first big bill can include two things at once:

  • a balancing payment for the tax you owe on your first year, and
  • an advance payment towards your second year, often based on the first year's figure.

Your friend did not pay double tax. She paid one year's tax and part of the next, close together, and nobody had warned her.

Why it catches first-year freelancers out

It catches people out because the advance is calculated from last year but paid out of this year's money. If your Tax Pot only ever held "last year's share", it will look short exactly when the bill lands. The timing is the surprise, not the amount.

There is also a quieter trap. Some people stop saving for a few months after they pay their first bill, out of relief. If an advance for this year was part of that bill, the pot needs to keep growing straight away.

How to prepare for your second-year tax bill

  1. Ask your tax authority's guidance or an accountant whether advance payments apply after your first return.
  2. Write down how the advance is worked out, for example a share of last year's bill, and when each part is due.
  3. Estimate your first year's tax from your profit so far, and work out roughly what the advance would be.
  4. Add both figures and the dates to your tax calendar, with reminders a month before.
  5. Keep setting aside at your full rate after you pay, because the pot now serves this year too.
  6. Run a quick check a month before each date: does the pot hold enough for what is due?

The one question to ask

The most useful sentence in your first year might be this one: "After my first self-employed return, will I be asked to pay anything in advance for the following year, and how is it worked out?" Put it on your list for your accountant, or search your tax authority's site using the words in this answer.

Estimating the size of it

If the advance is based on last year's bill, a rough estimate is enough. Take your expected first-year tax and apply the share your system uses. That tells you how much the pot needs by each date. The guide to quarterly and instalment taxes explains why these systems exist and how they differ.

Illustrative example

Jonah sees it coming

Jonah, 27, freelances as a web developer and started in April. In his third month, a friend's story about her bill made him ask an accountant the one question. The answer: yes, an advance would apply after his first return, worked out from his first year's bill. He estimated his first-year tax at about $7,500 and the advance at about $3,750, due within a few weeks of each other. He kept saving 27 percent from every invoice all year. When both were due, his pot held $12,200, so he paid them and still had a cushion. Jonah is fictional and the figures are illustrative.

A note for your tax calendar

Copy this into your calendar or Tax Pot notes and fill in your own dates.

Year two tax plan

Does an advance payment apply after my first return? yes / no / asking on ___

How it is worked out: ____

Balancing payment for year one: about ___ due ___

First advance for year two: about ___ due ___

Second advance (if any): about ___ due ___

Pot needed by the first date: ___. Pot today: ___

Your full self-employed tax deadlines calendar is the natural home for these dates.

Second-year mistakes that make the bill hurt

  • Stopping the set-aside after paying the first bill. If part of that bill was an advance, this year's tax is already being collected. Keep saving.
  • Assuming it won't apply because your income is small. Some systems have a threshold; others do not. Check rather than hope.
  • Cutting the advance without real numbers. Many systems let you reduce it if income falls, but cutting too far can mean interest later.
  • Spending a tax refund or surplus straight away. In year two your pot may need to cover more than one thing. Leave surplus there until you have checked the next date.
You'll know it's working when
  • You know, in writing, whether an advance payment applies to you.
  • Each payment due in year two has an estimated amount and a date in your calendar.
  • Your Tax Pot is on track to hold the total by the first date.
  • You kept saving at your full rate after the most recent payment.
  • If any of these is missing, ask the one question this week rather than waiting for the bill.

This is general information, not tax advice, and advance systems vary widely. An accountant can confirm your figures in one session. The pillar guide to your first year of freelance taxes shows where this fits, and the free Tax Readiness Quiz can help you see which part of your tax setup needs attention first.

Key takeaways

  • The double bill is usually last year's tax plus an advance on this year's.
  • Ask early whether advance payments apply to you and how they are worked out.
  • Put every year-two amount and date on your tax calendar.
  • Keep saving at your full rate after you pay; the pot now serves two years.

Questions people ask

Why is my second year tax bill so high as a freelancer?

In some tax systems, your first self-employed bill covers the tax for your first year plus an advance payment towards your second year. The UK's payments on account are one example. Both parts arrive close together, so the total can look like double. It is not extra tax, but it is earlier tax, and it needs to be planned for.

What are payments on account?

Payments on account are the UK's system of paying self-employed income tax in advance. After your first return, you may be asked to pay two instalments towards the next year, each usually based on half of the previous year's bill. Other countries have their own versions with different names, so check your own tax authority's guidance.

How do I know if advance payments apply to me?

Ask your tax authority's guidance or an accountant one direct question: after my first return, will I be asked to pay anything in advance for the following year? Many systems have a threshold below which no advance is needed, and some exclude people whose tax is mostly collected through a salary. The answer goes straight onto your tax calendar.

Can I reduce my advance tax payments if my income drops?

In many systems you can ask to reduce an advance payment if you expect lower income this year. Be careful: if you reduce it too far and your income turns out higher, you may owe interest on the difference. Base any reduction on real figures, and consider asking an accountant to check the estimate first.

Not financial or tax advice

FreelancerSave is educational and is not financial, tax, legal or investment advice. Tax rates and percentages are examples only; your real figures depend on your country, income and situation, so confirm them with an accountant or your tax authority. Examples are composites and results vary. Read the full disclaimer.

Cover of the free 30-Minute Freelance Money Reset

Free starter kit

Start a Tax Pot that can cover both bills

In 30 minutes you finish with your real Minimum Month number, a tax set-aside percentage, a separate Tax Pot account and your first three-way money split.

What happens next: an email asking you to reply VERIFY (it proves the address is yours), then your kit and 6 short emails over 12 days with free lessons, one of which describes our upcoming course and its waitlist. After that, at most one email a week. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Keep reading

More free guides